A Comparison: Littles Fires Everywhere

Littles Fires Everywhere Comparison

Celeste Ng & Hulu

Reviewed by Meghan Vermeer

Some of you may have heard of a popular new book called Little Fires Everywhere.  Maybe you have even heard of the television version on Hulu of the same story, made popular by Reese Witherspoon, who stars in the show herself.  Both are fantastic and explore a wide variety of perspectives and themes, and I’m here to give you the skinny on all of it!

The story primarily follows two very different families: the Richardsons and the Warrens.  The Richardsons are a high class family of six, and they are a product of the town in which they live:Shaker, Ohio, the most rule-following, “perfect” place in existence. The Warrens, just Mia and her daughter Pearl, move around frequently and find themselves in Shaker.  As the story continues, the two families become involved and jumbled in more ways than I can even think of!  Even though this entanglement provides enough drama in itself, the story quickly begins to center around another issue: Should Bebe Chow, an immigrant Chinese mother who abandoned her baby at a fire station, be given custody of her daughter over the McCulloughs, a rich white family who has since taken the child in?  Every character seems to have their own opinion, often influenced by a dark secret.

While the story remains quite similar in both the Hulu version and the novel, one of the biggest difference between them is that of the Warren’s race.  In the novel, Mia and Pearl’s race is never once mentioned.  It is a non-issue.  In fact, according to an interview I’ve found online, the Ng did not write Mia as a black woman because she didn’t feel she could do it justice as someone who is not black.  However, the Hulu version portrays Kerry Washington as Mia, and suddenly, the entire show becomes about race and the struggles of minorities to live within white communities like Shaker.  Race is a huge theme throughout the show, with tension between a black Mia and a white Elena Richardson, as well as the tension between the Chinese mother and white family who wants her daughter. 

Motherhood is a pivotal theme in both the novel and the show.  With the court case fighting over a Chinese baby and two (almost three…) of the main characters mothers themselves, motherhood was bound to come up.  However, in the show, it seems to be much more of a key point.  Kerry Washington does a beautiful job of portraying the passion that a mother can feel for her child.  Her performance is bound to give viewers chills. 

Another huge theme that isn’t explicitly mentioned in either the show or the novel is empathy.  The novel is written from an omniscient narrator’s perspective, which allows the reader to get into the heads of each character.  As events in the novel unfold, readers see the characters’ emotions, reasonings, and decisions, and thus develop a sense of empathy for them, no matter how crazy their actions really are.  The same thing happens in the show.  It does not follow just one character; rather, the show portrays each character and tells their story.  Once again, it is easy for viewers to become ensnared in the minds of the characters, empathizing with them.  

As with any recreation of a novel, there are some differences in plot between the two versions.  The biggest change is in the ending, but I won’t spoil it for you here.  Another difference would probably be the rating.  I could easily recommend the novel to some of my upper level high school students, but I would be uncomfortable recommending the show to impressionable minds, primarily because of sex scenes and innuendos that don’t show up or are glossed over in the novel.  The show is definitely geared toward women who are mothers themselves.

Overall, both the show and the novel are wonderfully put together, and I would highly recommend—but maybe consider reading the book first!  I watched the show first, and I think it impacted the way I read the book and viewed various parts, particularly the aforementioned race issues.  So check out the book, and then you will be able to find the show with Hulu subscription!  

If you want to keep up to date with our latest reviews, please remember to sign up for our email list!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.